Retro Friday Review: Everything on a Waffle by Polly Horvath


July 6, 2012 by Heidi

Retro Friday is a weekly meme hosted by Angie at Angieville and focuses on reviewing books from the past. This can be an old favorite, an under-the-radar book you think deserves more attention, something woefully out of print, etc. Everyone is welcome to join in at any time!

book cover of Everything on a Waffle by Polly Horvath

Title: Everything on a Waffle [Amazon|GoodReads]
Author: Polly Horvath [Website]
Standing: Stand alone novel, but a companion One Year in Coal Harbor is being released this fall!
Genre: Middle Grade, Contemporary
Published: April 5th, 2008 by Square Fish (Originally published April 4th, 2001 by Farrar, Straus & Giroux)
Format: Paperback; 176 pages
Source: Borrowed from my local library.
Challenge: Award Winning Reads Challenge

I believe that when most people read the phrase “emotional comfort food read” their minds will immediately turn to the Chicken Soup for the Soul line of books that were so popular more than a decade ago.  And yet, Polly Horvath’s Everything on a Waffle is exactly the type of book that fits under the emotional comfort food read heading.  To me, there is no better way to describe the deep-seated warmth that filled my insides as I consumed this book.  Bunbury readers know that I have a long standing love of Middle Grade fiction, but it might shock you to know I was hard pressed to bring to mind a single contemporary MG book that I have read that was not required reading for me in school (such as Shiloh, Because of Winn Dixie, etc.).  I couldn’t think of a single one that I’d read by choice, though I did enjoy many I was assigned in class.  That alone made Everything on a Waffle an out of the box read for me, and I am so glad I did it.

Everything on a Waffle tells the story of a young, redheaded Primrose Squarp (not Everdeen) who lives in the fishing village of Coal Harbor, British Columbia.  When her father fails to return from his ship one evening in the midst of a terrible storm, her mother follows him out into the sea on her small skiff.  Neither return, but Primrose refuses to accept the notion that they are dead.  She is certain that they are surviving together on an island somewhere, bound to return eventually.  Because of her firm belief she is ostracized and teased by others her age, pitied by adults, and left largely to fend for herself.  Primrose moves in with her uncle, a developer bent on changing everything about Coal Harbor who does little to help her local popularity.  Primrose, however, draws comfort from her beliefs, food, and companionship at The Girl in the Red Swing, a restaurant where no matter your order, everything is served on a waffle.

What is it about little redheaded girls that I find so incredibly loving and endearing?  Is it overflow from my love of Anne Shirley?  Or maybe it’s because I have a little redheaded niece I adore.  It’s hard to say, but Primrose Squarp has found herself neatly situated in good company.  She’s steadfast in her belief that her parents live, and really doesn’t care what anyone else thinks so long as they aren’t teasing and patronizing her.  Primrose’s insistence causes her to have many interesting conversations with townsfolk about times when they believed something contrary to the evidence.

Everything on a Waffle is full of rich characters, and what I found unusual about it was that other than Primrose, they were really all adults.  She has very little in the way of relationships with children her own age.  On the one hand, this is sad, but on the other hand her ability to connect with Miss Bowzer, the owner and chef at The Girl in the Red Swing, is incredibly endearing.  Her uncle, who turns his own life upside down to take Primrose in after her parents disappearance keeps her faith, supports her, and lets her do her own thing.  Unfortunately for Primrose, the rest of the souls in Coal Harbor cannot forgive her for not falling apart at her parents’ disappearance.  They cannot relate to a love so strong that one would follow another out into such a storm, or a faith so fervent a child refuses to accept her parents’ death.

I also appreciated that Everything on a Waffle forced me to see the other side of the coin in terms of development.  Coal Harbor is a fishing and whaling village, and with whaling soon to be outlawed and the navy withdrawing, it’s evident that many in the town will be losing work.  Primrose’s Uncle Jack is a developer who wants to turn Coal Harbor into a premiere tourist destination, and believes it’ll save the town.  Having grown up the daughter of a small business owner in a small town, I’ve always had a very negative outlook for those who wish to develop towns in this way.  I have the utmost disdain for tourist towns like Jackson Hole, Wyoming, that I honestly don’t even consider part of the state it has been developed so beyond the surrounding culture to attract only inhabitants from far away places.  Jack spends much of Everything on a Waffle working to buy up properties and businesses and replace them with more corporate or touristy options.  Polly Horvath’s story didn’t really change my mind or make me okay with this sort of thing (and I don’t think it was trying to), but it did show me the other point of view.  The idea that Jack is working to save Coal Harbor, provide jobs, and generate income for locals in new ways is positive.  I’m not going to stop gearing up to protest the building of a Wall-Mart in my hometown, but I will be more mindful of this perspective in the future.

Finally, the most delightful aspect of Everything on a Waffle (besides the paperback cover, which I adore), was the food.  Each chapter closes out with a recipe for an item mentioned therein.  Even the recipes are written with heart and humor, and they vary from the simplicity of how to boil potatoes perfectly to the complexities of cinnamon rolls.  I think it would be so much fun to read this book together with a child, and after each chapter work together to make the recipe mentioned.  Polly Horvath understands how food can be a comfort and make you feel at home when the rug has been pulled out from under you and you are surrounded by nothing else that is familiar.  Reading Everything on a Waffle was kind of like getting a good hug, and I thoroughly enjoyed it.

Likelihood that I’ll be back for more:  Most certainly! I have a copy of One Year in Coal Harbor for review, and will be back to tell you about it closer to its release date.

Recommended for: Middle Grade contemporary readers, those who like to cook, or love food in books.

Real life repercussions of reading this book:  Have you ever believed something contrary to the evidence?  I’ve been thinking about this while reading Primrose’s story, and I’m sad to report I can’t think of a single instance where I have.  I’ve always been too practical, but I often wish I weren’t.

Get a second opinion:
Have you reviewed Everything on a Waffle by Polly Horvath?  Let me know, and I’ll link your review here.


If you liked that you might like this:


  1. Elizabeth says:

    What a lovely review! I don’t normally read MG, so generally I skip or skim reviews of it, but that cover/title caught my eye and your review made it very apparent how much you love this book. I might have to make an exception and try it out, it sounds pretty heartwarming!

    • Heidi says:

      Thank you, I’m glad this one caught your attention even though MG isn’t usually your thing! It is a very heartwarming read. =)

  2. Ahhh, this book sounds so sweet. I would love to read this with my girls (who are currently enjoying Howl’s Moving Castle very much, btw) and then try out the recipes.

    I don’t think I’ve ever believed something in spite of the evidence either. Not that I can remember. :(

    Would it be too spoilery to ask if her parents are actually dead?

    • Heidi says:

      It would be a tad spoilery, but I’ll tell you in a DM on Twitter if you want! 😛

      So glad that your girls are enjoying Howl’s Moving Castle!

  3. Oh my gracious, you almost have me wanting to throw all my other books down and read this one. First of all, the cover is precious. Second of all, it sounds delightful. I love MG. Brilliant review, Bunbury.

    • Heidi says:

      Thanks, Asheley! This was so charming, I can’t believe I’d never even heard of it. Particularly since it’s a Newberry winner.

  4. […] Retro Friday: Everything on a Waffle by Polly Horvath Graphic Novel review: Cinderella: Fables are Forever by Chris Roberson Salute Your Shorts: On the Day I Died by Candace Fleming With Bated Breath: July New Releases Top Reads of 2012 Thus Far Being Friends With Boys by Terra Elan McVoy Author Guest Post with Terra Elan McVoy Salute Your Shorts: The Assassin and the Desert by Sarah J. Maas I’ve Got Your Number by Sophie Kinsella Rebel McKenzie by Candice Ransom  Share this:Like this:LikeBe the first to like this. This entry was posted in In My Mailbox and tagged In My Mailbox. […]

  5. Ahhhh. I want to read this. F’realz little red headed girls are the best heroines. And okay, I like reading about food even though it makes me super hungry. And like, I think there’s always two sides of a coin when it comes to big issues.

    Fabulous review, Heidi!

  6. […] Year in Coal Harbor [Amazon|Goodreads] Author: Polly Horvath [Website] Standing: Sequel to Everything on a Waffle–each book can be read as a stand alone. Genre: Middle Grade, Contemporary […]

  7. […] the Kirkus review, or one from Bunbury in the Stacks (spoiler […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge

RSS FeedE-mailTwitterGoodreads

My Current Bunbury

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner


FTC Disclaimer

While the source for each book I review is posted within its review, please assume unless otherwise stated that books reviewed on Bunbury in the Stacks were received free from the author or publisher in exchange for an honest review.